Mathematical Framework · Anno MMXXVI

The Hackfort Equation

A quantum criticality index: how much of a rate exists only because of the quantum world
Sabrina Hackfort · Independent Researcher · ORCID 0009-0007-7458-2487
❦ ❦ ❦

Die Natur geht durch Wände. Ich habe nur gezählt, wie oft.

Nature walks through walls. I have only counted how often.

Classical models describe chemistry as particles climbing over energy barriers. Yet protons and hydrides can also tunnel through them, and coherence can shape how a reaction proceeds. The Hackfort Equation condenses this into a single dimensionless number, the quantum criticality index ΦH. It states how much of a system's behaviour exists only because of quantum effects.

Axiom 1 — Quantum Discrepancy (Hackfort, 2026; sharpened October 2026)

For every system S possessing at least one quantum-mechanical degree of freedom, there exists an observable 𝒪 such that

Δ(S) ≡ ⟨𝒪⟩QM − ⟨𝒪⟩class ≠ 0.

The size |Δ(S)| measures how far the classical description misses. The sign is not universal: it depends on the observable and on the regime. Tunneling raises most reaction rates, while quantum effects lower Planck's radiation density at high frequency, where the classical Rayleigh–Jeans law diverges.

Original statement of 29 March 2026: the same, with the additional claim Δ(S) ≥ 0. That claim holds for tunneling rates in the region shown below, not in general; it is kept here as part of the record.

The Equation

ΦH(S, t) = Σi wi · ai(t) · ηi · (1 + |λ̃i(t)|)
ηi = 1 − 1/κi · κi = kQM / kclass · λ̃i(t) = (d/dt ln Γi) / λref

ηi — the quantum fraction. The part of a channel's computed rate that exists only because of tunneling, (kQM − kclass)/kQM: 0 for a purely classical channel, approaching 1 when tunneling dominates. It is not the share of the rate carried below the barrier top; the two differ by the reflection above the top (published note).

ai(t) — functionality. How active the channel is: 1 for a healthy enzyme, below 1 when inhibited, towards 0 when lost. Written αi in the original statement of 29 March 2026; ai avoids confusion with the Eckart parameter α.

λ̃i(t) — coherence dynamics. How fast the quantum landscape changes, derived from the Lindblad master equation for open quantum systems.

wi — weight. The share of channel i in the system's quantum rate, wi = kQM,i / Σj kQM,j, so that Σwi = 1. This choice is not free: with it, and with ai = 1 and λ̃i = 0, ΦH is exactly the quantum fraction of the total rate.

The structure is multiplicative, and this encodes a physical statement: without a quantum effect (η = 0) there is no quantum criticality, whatever the dynamics. Coherence can amplify quantum behaviour, but it cannot create it from nothing.

Properties. For channels with κi ≥ 1:

  1. ΦH ≥ 0.
  2. ΦH is dimensionless, since every factor is a ratio.
  3. ΦH = 0 if and only if every channel is classical or inactive.
  4. ΦH < maxi (1 + |λ̃i|).

The Heart: the Quantum Fraction η

Everything rests on η, and η rests on κ, the ratio of the rate with tunneling to the rate without it, both in the same model. The tool ZENO computes κ with a validated tunneling model (symmetric Eckart barrier). The plate below shows the landscape of η: where the quantum world rules and where classical physics suffices.

barrier frequency ν̃ →
temperature T →
Temperature
Height: the quantum fraction η = 1 − 1/κ for a hydrogen transfer over a barrier of 13.2 kcal/mol, across temperatures from 60 to 400 K and barrier frequencies from 400 to 2000 cm⁻¹. Steep barriers and cold temperatures lift η towards 1, where almost the whole computed rate exists only because of tunneling. Red: the enzyme formate dehydrogenase, a point from published QM/MM simulations. Drag to turn the plate.

Checked, Not Assumed

The first check of the equation against independent data: tunneling coefficients κ for the hydride transfer in formate dehydrogenase, from QM/MM simulations in the literature. ZENO is fitted once at 300 K and predicts the other temperatures.

Temperatureκ (QM/MM)η from QM/MMη predicted (ZENO)
278 K6,30,840,86
300 K5,00,800,80
318 K4,30,770,75

At 300 K η = 0.80: without tunneling, four fifths of the computed rate of this enzyme step would be missing; the rate is five times the classical one.

Where the Discrepancy Is Positive

For reaction rates, the original claim Δ(S) ≥ 0, that is κ ≥ 1, is a physical statement, and so it can be tested. For the Eckart barrier, the standard one-dimensional tunneling model, it holds for every symmetric barrier computed (3249 points, barrier heights from 10−4 to 103 kBT, hν‡/kBT from 10−3 to 400; this is numerical evidence, a proof is still open), and for every asymmetry up to a factor of seven. It fails for strongly asymmetric barriers with a small barrier height. There, part of the wave is reflected at the step between the two sides even above the barrier top, this loss outweighs the gain from tunneling, and κ < 1. For small barriers the boundary is exact:

Boundary of κ ≥ 1 for the Eckart Barrier (Hackfort, October 2026)
ln κ = vmin · [ 1 − (r − 1)/6 ]
r = Vmax/Vmin · vmin = Vmin/kBT · leading order for small vmin

The factor 1/6 is the thermally averaged reflection at a sharp step, ∫0∞ (√(s+1) − √s)4 ds = 1/6. The sign of η therefore changes exactly at r = 7. Numerically the critical ratio approaches 7 (7,0100 at vmin = 10−4, 7,0002 at 10−6), and the formula agrees with the full calculation to 0,1 %.

V1/kBTV2/kBThν‡/kBTκη
300,380,767−0,30
100,11280,682−0,47
10,120,998−0,002
4421,222+0,18

Every value computed twice, with the library ELIAH (formerly NETI) and with an independent 50-digit implementation written directly from the Eckart potential; they agree to 13 digits. The first row is chemically realistic: at 300 K, a strongly endothermic step (75 against 0,75 kJ/mol) with an imaginary frequency of about 1670 cm⁻¹.

Enzymatic hydrogen transfers have barriers many kBT high, far from this region. There η ≥ 0 holds, and with it the properties above. The positive sign is not universal, but for the Eckart barrier its scope is now known exactly.

Scope and Corrections

Science moves forward by correcting itself, so the record is kept open here. κ must be the ratio of rates with and without tunneling in the same model. It is not the kinetic isotope effect. An earlier version of this page used isotope effects as κ, and those values are withdrawn. Quantum effects can also lower a rate (see “Where the Discrepancy Is Positive”); η is then negative, and the properties of ΦH listed above hold for channels with κ ≥ 1. The earlier pharmacological corollary, that drug doses are wrong by a factor κ, is withdrawn as well. Clinical doses rest on measured clearance, which already contains any tunneling. The real lever is deliberate deuteration. Its strategy tool ZENO-DX, tested on the approved drug deutetrabenazine with measured inputs only, predicts one of the two active metabolites correctly and underestimates the other; an earlier, more favourable version of this test is withdrawn. The corollaries on biodiversity and on cryptographic systems remain hypotheses that have not yet been tested.

Built on It

The tunnelling fraction of a reaction rate (Zenodo, 2026, doi:10.5281/zenodo.23531953): the published note that fixes the conventions for η, states what it measures, gives 1197 certified reference values and proposes the Hackfort index with its exact weight rule. ZENO: the tunneling and deuteration toolkit that computes η, checked against four published enzyme simulations. ELIAH (formerly NETI): Eckart tunneling coefficients checked against certified values, the reference behind the boundary above. Radix Riemanniana: the author's second construction, in number theory.